Debunking the Body Autonomy Argument

Definition of Body Autonomy:
Body autonomy is the right for a person to govern what happens to their body without external influence or coercion. 

This right is often cited as a justification for legalized abortion, but we need to look a little deeper.

The Body Autonomy argument is about the right to refuse to get a medical procedure that could save someone, not some right to get a medical procedure that would kill.

The Body Autonomy argument is about having the choice. In the case of a pregnancy, the vast majority of the time the woman made a choice already, and the reasonable result is pregnancy. Preventing her from killing her unborn baby does not negate the fact that she already chose and choice is not being denied.

The Body Autonomy argument relies on the fetus being something other than a human person. If the fetus is a human person, then abortion is literally forcing a medical procedure on a person to kill them for the convenience of someone else, and the life and death situation would take precendence. The baby comes first, because her life is at stake, versus the mother’s convenience, comfort, or career. Even the UN Population Fund says “Having bodily autonomy does not mean any person gets to undermine the health, rights or autonomy of others. Individuals have the right to choose whether to have sex or get pregnant, for example, but they are not entitled to impose these choices on others.” This means that a mother has no right to undermine the health of her baby-in-utero, if that baby is a human person.

Oftentimes with abortion a young woman is pressured into an abortion she doesn’t want because her parents or the father of her child don’t want to deal with the consequences. This coercion causes both an unwanted medical procedure on the new mother and the death of an unborn baby.

In Washington v. Glucksberg (1997), “And although Casey (Planned Parenthood vs Casey (1992)) recognized that many of the rights and liberties protected by the Due Process Clause sound in personal autonomy, it does not follow that any and all important, intimate, and personal decisions are so protected. Casey did not suggest otherwise.”

The 14th Ammendment: “No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” Note that the first clause is about citizens, but the second and third are about “persons”. If a fetus is a person, it is given “equal protection of the laws,” protecting “life, liberty,” et cetera.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

You might be a redneck if…

your road is Cracker Swamp Dirt Rd.
Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

End Of Summer 2018 Update: Katie’s Health

So, I haven’t posted in quite a while… just fill this part in with the usual excuses.  That will save me typing them out.  😉

Katie started getting Neupogen shots in the spring, to try to bring her neutrophil count up to Continue reading

Posted in Family, Health, News | Leave a comment

Donations Wanted

If you have old aquariums (mostly 10 and 20 gallon), rabbit cages, reptile habitats, etc. that you would like to donate to the KBC Nature Center (first floor of the Tower), we are interested in more housing for the animals.  If you’re interested in helping out more, or with something specific, we’d love to hear from you.  Call Jonathan or Laurel for more info.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Kansas Bible Camp: The Nature Center

Well, we are attempting to fill a vacancy at the Camp this year.

Rick Khol has been faithfully overseeing the Nature Center and doing a lot of the preaching at KBC for years, and has recently felt Continue reading

Posted in Animal, Events, Family, News | Leave a comment

Bass Pro Shop (and another Children’s Mercy appointment)

So, Sunday evening we drove up to KC for another appointment for Katie.  This is the appointment Continue reading

Posted in Family, Health, Kids | Leave a comment

Celebration of Wayne’s Life

Yesterday, April 28th, we had a Life Celebration for Wayne.

Many people came to honor his life and to bless Genene.  The service was live-streamed, and is posted on Continue reading

Posted in Faith, Family, News | Leave a comment

Precious Moments – Part Two

While we were in the St Louis area, about 7 pm, Laurel’s brother Eric called to let us know that their dad, Wayne Byrd, had been in a car accident, they suspected heart problems, he’d needed resuscitation, and was in the hospital and they were doing tests.

As we discussed what to do, got counsel from friends, talked to Eric, and prayed, we made the decision to Continue reading

Posted in Events, Family, Health, News | Leave a comment

Precious Moments – Part One

We took this past weekend intending to drive to St Louis for a wedding, then back to Kansas City for a doctor’s appointment for Katie.  Since we only had five kids going, we borrowed Dad’s minivan (wow! a small group.)

We opted for the southern route from Hutch to StL, Continue reading

Posted in Events, Family, News | Leave a comment

Anniversary of the Midnight Ride of Paul Revere

and I noticed something odd about Bing’s description:

Continue reading

Posted in Events, News | Leave a comment